Downgrading of the Sapling hits home

December 07, 2013 08:54am
Monmouth Park 615 X 400
Photo: Eclipse Sportswire


When the American Graded Stakes Committee came out with its listing of U.S. Graded and Listed Stakes Races for 2014 yesterday, the downgrading of one race hit home more than any of the others. As of next year, Monmouth Park’s Sapling Stakes will no longer be a graded stakes race. That’s a shame, as it is a race with a wonderful tradition. In its nearly seventy years of history, The Sapling roll call of winners includes a most impressive list of racing stars. Horses like Blue Peter, Needles, Hail to Reason, Sir Gaylord, Buckpasser, Foolish Pleasure, Alydar, Rockhill Native, Bet Twice, Carson City, Gilded Time, Hennessy, and Smoke Glacken have come to Monmouth and won the Jersey Shore oval’s premier race for juvenile colts.

The Sapling not only possesses a rich and storied history, but it also happens to be one of my favorite childhood races. As a horse racing crazy kid growing up in New Jersey, there were plenty of great tracks within driving distance, and Monmouth Park was one of my favorites. Other than the Monmouth Invitational, since renamed the Haskell Invitational, the Sapling was tops on the list of Monmouth races that I looked forward to every summer. Year in, and year out, it attracted many of the season’s best two-year-olds. So much so, that I now find it somewhat hard to believe its relative insignificance on the American racing landscape.

I cannot blame the American Graded Stakes Committee for dropping the Sapling as a graded stakes race. It is not what it once was. With the current trend of many of the best young horses only making a start or two before the Breeders’ Cup, a late summer, six furlong stakes race in New Jersey is simply no longer in vogue. I still have my memories, though, of the once proud race.

Back in the day, the Sapling was not only a graded race, it was a grade 1. By 1986, however, it had been downgraded to a grade 2, but the winner of that edition was grade one all the way. Owned and trained by a pair of New Jersey mainstays, Robert Levy and Jimmy Croll, I was lucky enough to see Bet Twice break his maiden in near impossible fashion. To see an untested horse come from the clouds to power by his opponents in the Monmouth Park stretch is something that almost never happened at at the speed favoring Jersey shore oval, especially with the babies. Bet Twice was far from a normal Thoroughbred though, so when I had the chance to see him again in the Sapling, I was excited. This time, though, he would be facing probably the most talked about young colt at the time, Faster Than Sound.

Faster Than Sound had blitzed his competition to date, and in very fast time. The regular rider of both colts, Craig Perret chose the favorite, meaning that Bet Twice was available for the best young rider in the nation, Chris Antley. I liked Perret, but this young Antley kid was really something.

When the gates sprung open, Homebuilder, from the Woody Stephens barn, broke on top, as Faster Than Sound chased in close pursuit. Antley, meanwhile, had Bet Twice much closer than in his first two wins, and was sitting in third on the outside. When Faster Than Sound surged to the lead on the far turn, Bet Twice followed. Perret asked the colt, that he had chosen, in early stretch for more, but the battle would not last long. Bet Twice loped up to the favorite and ran right on by. He hit the wire an easy 2 ½ length winner. 

In a meeting of undefeated colts, it was the 7-2 second choice who proved much the best over the 3-10 hyped horse. It was a satisfying result for this then young fan and handicapper. The nice colt, Homebuilder, stayed on well and finished close to Faster Than Sound in third, some 16 lengths clear of the fourth horse. Needless to say, Bet Twice was my favorite juvenile of 1986.

Bet Twice would go on to win numerous big races, including the following year’s Haskell in a real slobberknocker over Alysheba and Lost Code. He also competed against Alysheba in all three legs of the Triple Crown. Finishing second to him in both the Kentucky Derby and Preakness, before romping home in the Belmont Stakes by 14 lengths. In all, he won more than $3.3 million at a time when that figure really meant something.

Graded or not, Bet Twice’s win was just one of many great memories that I have of the Sapling Stakes. 


comments powered by Disqus

Older Comments about Downgrading of the Sapling hits home...

That should be some top horses for their signature events.
It took about 40 to be guaranteed a spot in the gate, so perhaps if you spread the points around to more races so that top finish isn't ten but less might work and encourage more racing and have more tracks getting done top horses for their fans.
Buck, afriend had an interesting idea and concept. Due to the esteem and privaledge of running in the Kentucky Derby. The top 15 point earners get the usual guaranteed entry. On the next 5 slots,take the top 10 pt earners and put their names in a hat. Have a lottery system.The 5 names selected are in. The balance become AEs'. This would encourage more to run their horses. The incentive would be to get into the top 15.
Tom. I believe you what nine races for two yr olds that earn points to the Derby. What you could do is spread the points around to more races or to change some of the races each year depending on who from the race, if any horse gets into the gate at the Derby.
Personally Buck,i think rewarding KD points to 2 year olds is unfair. It rewards the more precocious bred horses.The ones that more than likely will never have a chance to win the Derby. But the thrill and Honor to just be in the Starting Gate,will more than likely prevent serious contenders from entering.I honestly do not think the Derby committee realy cares much of what horses enter the Starting gate. They know that one way or the other,the top 5-7 horses will qualify ,because of their overall abilities. I have said it before and will continue to say it. If you put 20 claimers to run in the Derby and never told anyone.It would not lose its' luster. The brand has strengthened so much over the past decade. It is no longer a race,it is an event like the Super Bowl.
Each year Monmouth gets less relevant in stakes action
This is where the KD points system could make a difference by awarding points to more of these legendary races to keep them relevant.
Laz,not only The Young A merica,but that was a time when The Meadowlands was thriving. When they started the night racing,it brought an entire new perspective to the Gotham City area. Always loved the "Ernie Banks" lets play2 concept on Saturdays. Belmont Park in the daytime and then The Meadowlands as the nightcap.Did not get better than that.
Clearly the Juvenile is doing no one any good. Maybe it should be discontinued
Too many of the old stakes are disappearing. I remember the Young American Stakes. It was a G1 at the Meadowlands and was won by two future Derby winners, Spectacular Bid and Swale as well as Deputy Minister. The Breeders Cup heavily impacted it because it was run in the fall. In 1991 it was switched to turf and was downgraded to a G2 and then a G3 and disappeared altogether in 1995, after 19 editions.
One by one many historic races are being downgraded and will soon become irrelevant. VERY SAD!
I am sorry about the Sapling. Years ago for two yr old colts it was a must win along with the Garden State for championship honors. It was up there with the Hopeful, the Futurity and the Champagne Stakes. The Sorority and the Gardenia were must wins for the fillies for top honors. Sad to see the change.
Way back when the Haskell/Monmouth Invitational was not that big a deal. The Sapling and Sorority were just as big and were actually my favorites. We were looking at the new stars.

Related Pages

ZATT's Star of the Week
Higher Power

Meet Brian Zipse

Brian has been a passionate fan of horse racing his entire life. Taken to the races at a very young age, he has been lucky enough to see all the greats in person from Secretariat, Forego, and Ruffian through Rachel Alexandra, Zenyatta, American Pharoah and Justify. Before coming to the Nation, Brian displayed his love for the sport through the development of his horse racing website, which quickly became one of the most popular blogs in the game. His new racing partnership venture, Derby Day Racing, invites more fans to experience the thrill of racehorse ownership.

The Editor of Horse Racing Nation from 2010-2017, Brian authored a daily column as Zipse at the Track, created the popular racing show, HorseCenter and added his editorial flare to the overall content of the website. Now a Senior Writer for HRN, Brian continues to contribute his thoughts on racing, as well as hosting HorseCenter. A big supporter of thoroughbred aftercare, he serves as the President of The Exceller Fund.

Brian's work has also been published on several leading industry sites. He has consulted for leading contest site Derby Wars, is both a Hall of Fame and NTRA poll voter, and is a Vox Populi committee member. 

A horse owner and graduate of DePaul University, Brian lives just outside of Louisville with his wife Candice and daughter Kendra.

Best of the Blogs

Top Stories