• La Coronel (5-1) leads them all the way in the Grade 1 Queen Elizabeth II Challenge Cup.Posted 6 days ago
  • Rubilinda (6-5) finds the wire just in time to take the Pebbles Stakes.Posted 6 days ago
  • Engage (1-2) rolls home from last to win the Grade 3 Futurity Stakes.Posted 6 days ago
  • Bolt d'Oro is the 12-1 favorite in the current Las Vegas line for Kentucky Derby 2018.Posted 9 days ago
  • Romantic Vision (6-1) takes the sloppy Spinster (G1) at Keeneland.Posted 12 days ago
  • Unique Bella (1-5) returns with a clear victory in the L. A. Woman (G3) at Santa Anita.Posted 12 days ago
  • Flameaway (5-1) wins a three-horse photo finish in the Dixiana Bourbon (G3) at a wet Keeneland.Posted 12 days ago
  • War Flag (9-1) wins the stretch battle in Belmont's Flower Bowl (G1).Posted 12 days ago
  • Separationofpowers (9-5) impresses in the Frizette at Belmont Park.Posted 12 days ago
  • Roy H (4-5) lives up to favoritism in the Grade 1 Santa Anita Sprint Championship.Posted 13 days ago
Breeders' Cup 2017
HRN Original Blog:
Travis Stone

Wise Dan: Some Perspective On His Shadwell Defeat

Wise Dan wins 2013 Firecracker at Churchill Downs.
Photo: Churchill Downs/Reed Palmer

It’s both human and horseplayer nature to instantly react, label and categorize performances on the racetrack, especially when they include a Horse of the Year. In today’s “what have you done for me lately?” society, everything is pigeonholed with a reason why.

Wise Dan’s loss in the Shadwell this past weekend at Keeneland raised a lot of eyebrows and quick reactions on the various channels of horse racing including such silly claims as Wise Dan being “over the top” or compromised by a “speed bias.” Simply put, he was beat on the square by a horse who got loose on a clear early lead and ran his lungs out.

From a high level, Wise Dan’s loss on Saturday will make his bid for a repeat Horse of the Year title significantly tougher. Game on Dude and Princess of Sylmar now have the upper-hand in that race. On the other hand, it might also prime him for a repeat win in the Breeders’ Cup Mile.


Lost The Prep, Won The Race 

Contrary to the belief of many, sometimes it’s okay to lose. No, it’s not fun, but in horse racing a loss can set you up for bigger gains down the road as an owner or trainer and a horseplayer as well. In the context of the Breeders’ Cup, here are two examples...

Blame rose to the top of the handicap division rather quickly in 2010 and looked primed for a run at Horse of the Year until he was a victim of circumstances in the Jockey Club Gold Cup. Haynesfield, who was 5-for-5 at Belmont Park, coasted on an uncontested lead posting a six furlong split of 1:13-1/5. It was game over for anyone looking to rally from off the pace as Haynesfield won by four lengths over Blame, who was two lengths clear of closer Fly Down.


In the Breeders’ Cup Classic, the tables were turned. With a significantly stronger pace, Blame rallied to win beating Zenyatta by a head on the wire. Fly Down, who lost by six lengths in the Jockey Club Gold Cup, finished third. There were no easy leads for Haynesfield and he ended-up 11th beaten more than 22 lengths.

Last year, Trinniberg won the Breeders’ Cup Sprint at 13-1 despite losing his prior race to 3-year-olds in the Gallant Bob at Parx where the pace was off-the-charts fast.

The opening quarter of the Gallant Bob was 21-2/5 to a half in 43-4/5 seconds! Those are splits you rarely see anywhere, especially on the east coast and much less at Parx. Trinniberg was right on the hot pace while going three wide around the turn.

The eventual winner, Well Spelled, came from 12 lengths back to win posting a 16 point career-best jump on Beyer figures. Trinniberg hung around to lose by just a half-length while still more than three lengths clear of third. Interestingly, third place finisher Private Zone, who was also involved in the pace, will be one of the shorter prices in this year’s Sprint.


Blame and Trinniberg are just two examples in a long list of horse’s who, despite not visiting the winner’s circle, still ran well enough to warrant a chance next time out.


Closer Look: Wise Dan's Shadwell Performance 

With that in mind, rather than dissecting Wise Dan’s Shadwell performance in the context of his overall career or Horse of the Year status, let’s look at it objectively:

* The winner, Silver Max, is a front-running machine. When allowed a clear lead, he produces his best stuff. In fact, all of his 11 victories (from 22 starts, pretty stout) were earned on the front-end. He has never passed a horse and gone on to win.

* Wise Dan was stuck wide on both turns. According to Trakus, he traveled 41 more feet than Silver Max, which is approximately five lengths. Silver Max won by 1-¼ lengths.

* Wise Dan did this while chasing a strong pace to boot. “Chasing while wide” is hard to do, especially when the pace is strong or fast. Despite this, Wise Dan was still in the hunt at mid-stretch. Hogy and Handsome Mike, who were second and third early, wilted to 8th and 10th beaten 10-¾ and 14-¾ lengths respectively.

The conclusion? Silver Max ran huge but so did Wise Dan. It’s fun to admire perfection, but perfection is rare, especially in horse racing. Another digit in the loss column is nothing more than a stat. I believe anyone downgrading their opinion of Wise Dan because of his loss on Saturday is being short-sighted.

From a horseplayer’s perspective, Wise Dan might be a good bet against in the Mile. After all, he ran such a big race at Woodbine, followed-up by another strong effort at Keeneland, that the lemon might be squeezed a bit too dry. It all depends on his price.

Regardless, just because he lost a race does not mean he’s any less talented, fast or brilliant and hopefully, for the sake of Wise Dan fans everywhere, a bounce-back run is in order.


comments powered by Disqus

Older Comments about Wise Dan: Some Perspective On His Shadwell Defeat...

Where i beg to differ on 1 point is the terminology used.Dan chased the pace.Far from what i saw.J.R. just parked himoutside for clear running.He easily cruised into 2nd place.The one correct statement is that Silver Max ran his eyeballs out.Although J.R.showed Dan the whip and shook him up.Never with any intensity.Forget the fact he was not running on his preffered surface. H e was also asked to go an additional 16th of a mile,due to the Surface Change.In most speed figures that have come out(at least the ones that mean anything to me) Dan ran basically the same race he ran in the past.He is comig into this race in the same manner he came into last years race.Exactly the same amount of racce and spacing.With Silver Max and Obviously in the race,if i were the Lopresti/Fink/Velasquez team.I would be extremely confident in the potential trip he will get.Should Dan lose this race.It will not be because he is a tired or spent horse.It will be because somebody layed down a Herculean effort to beat him.
I think it's interesting that you consider Wise Dan to be a probable play against in the BC Mile, Travis. After his loss at Keeneland, I myself wondered if maybe the "lemon had been squeezed dry" at Woodbine prior to his Keeneland effort rather than afterwards. Just a thought.
Somebody needs a hug.
11-1 longest shot on the board in a 10 horse field, don't see that everyday.
Finally post a genuine sentiment and look at what I get.
Do not make fun of cutie,that is Jennas pal.
OK, I'm all in based on 0%_110%.
Mums,cutie is 20-1 in the 9th. 20% handicapping-80% rooting like crazy
you are to busy quoting edgar
you are to busy quoting edgar
you are to busy quoting edgar
Here I’m looking at the PP’s *Asleep at the Wheel* and you’re cashing. How about a little lead time, Nathan :D
Mums,SoCal P6 juicy,P6 stables getting involved nicely. Looking for investors.you game for a cut.
Mums ,by now you should know me better.If i post as a fan ,i tell you i am rooting.Hope you listened Laz.
Really enjoy when you post a horse in a race to check out. It would be nice if you’d post * %Word_%Loyalty_%Handicapping* Blabs.
I think you’d have more fun trying to *hook up* and hustle Maylan’s book, but that’s just me. Don’t watch NFL Network today, it’s wall-to-wall bad news :(
Laz if you are playing today.At keeneland race 5.The #5 has a nice shot.(commercial flight)
Laz, i am so fed up with these guys.I promised some friends that i would maybe hook up at a Sports Bar and watch the game.Worst thing is,if they win by fluke.They are only 1 game out of 1rst. Bears have excellent D Line. eLI better be careful tonite.It could get physical.
Tom, what is doing? I’m preparing for another shell-shocking performance tonight. I heard on the QT that the Bears are going to be really, really ugly. As for not winning every time, isn’t that the message on the G-men’s dressing room wall. Someone should put up another message: “It’s okay to win one once in a while.”

Related Pages

About Travis Stone

Travis Stone is the track announcer at Louisiana Downs and one of the founders of Horse Racing Nation. A lifelong fan of the sport, Travis became interested in racing after hundreds of trips to Saratoga while growing-up. He quickly became captivated by the sound of the announcer and decided to become one himself. In addition to announcing, Travis serves double-duty as Mutuel Manager as well while helping out with all aspects of the racing at Louisiana Downs.

Travis On Twiter

About This Blog

I used to blog on my personal website but decided to join the amazing roster of contributors at Horse Racing Nation. Opinions and thoughts presented here are my own.

Related Stories

Top Stories