Race of the Week 2017
HRN Original Blog:
Bay Area Backstretch

Bumpy Ride on the Kentucky Derby Trail

Kentucky Derby aspirations may have changed for the two pre-race favorites following the running of the El Camino Real Derby on Saturday.

Lets start with the 1-2 favorite,
Comma to the Top.

Racing for the first time in two months, ‘Comma broke alertly, lugged out during the run to the first turn then settled in a great stalking position onto the backstretch.

Following pacesetter Jakesam, ‘Comma moved up on the far turn, looked poised to take control and then just flattened out. In the run through the final sixteenth, he lugged out again bumping eventual winner Silver Medallion, and faded to finish a well beaten 4th, almost five lengths behind.

After the race, Comma to the Top’s trainer Peter Miller called Corey Nakatani’s ride “Interesting” but said the jock would ride the horse next time.

It wasn’t as interesting to the stewards at Golden Gate, who handed Nakatani a 3 day suspension for “ failure to make a proper effort to maintain a straight course in the stretch and causing interference.”

I don’t expect the 11th ranked horse in Horse Racing Nation’s list of
2011 Kentucky Derby Contenders to stay on the derby trail much longer.

The same can be said for 5-2 second choice,
Positive Response.

The son of Pomeroy, also tested his come from behind style, dropped much further behind than most thought he would be, under jockey Julien Couton.

“It wasn’t a perfect race or perfect trip for us,” said ‘Response trainer William E. Morey. “We didn’t expect to be last and that far behind.”

‘Response was sixth at the quarter pole and fifth, trailing by over six lengths at the half mile mark. Probably too far back for a horse that had only come from off the pace to win once, and was a lot closer to the lead in that win.

When Couton asked ‘Response to move up on the far turn, there was no response.

Fourth into the stretch, he battled gamely down the lane and finished third, beaten only two non-threatening lengths.

“He ran good, I just think the two ahead of us got better trips than we did, that’s racing luck,” Morey said.

And as for the future of Positive Response?

“We will look at races the next tier down. It probably won’t be a Grade 1,” Morey said.

What can we say about the winner,
Silver Medallion?

Well I guess you could kick yourself if you didn’t bet on Russell Baze in a big race at Golden Gate Fields. The morning line second choice, slipped to 6-1, and won the race by 1 ¼ lengths.

The win was the third straight El Camino Real for Baze and saved the day for trainer Steve Assmussen. The trainer had earlier watched his highly touted Tapizar run 5th as the odds on choice in the Robert B Lewis Stakes at Santa Anita.

That race was won by Anthony’s Cross, who scratched out of the El Camino to run there. While Anthony’s Cross is now slated to be looking at the Santa Anita Derby, the plans of Tapizar, Positive Response, Comma to the Top and Silver Medallion are up in the air.

Weird how one race may change the plans of so many derby hopefuls.


comments powered by Disqus

Older Comments about Bumpy Ride on the Kentucky Derby Trail...

i can't throw him out yet, that was his first 1 1/8 and he just didn't even really fire that day. he made his move and drifted into silver medallion. i am going to wait and see his next race before tossing him out. he could have just clunked.
they seem to have rated him nicely in his prior race in which JPs Gust closed on him quickly in the stretch.if they go the extra 1/16 in that race he loses at about the same distance.
Actually, his trainer said that they tried to rate CTTT, and they won't do that again. Let's see what his next race shows us before you say he def can't get 9 furlongs.
You guys are all right. I was totally turned off by CTTT in this race. I would think Miller would have had him ready by workouts but obviously he wasn't. It will be interesting to see if Nakatani is on him next time. I also think Positive Response is better near the lead. He was too far back to make a run. Silver Medallion looked very good but chances Baze riding him again are bleak since Baze seems to never get the call away from GGF.
I think Comma to the Top may have some distance issues. He flattened out with practically no rally in the stretch at all. If noting else he should get some great conditioning out of this race and come back with a little more spark but I don't think he'll make a good Derby prospect. Positive Response and Silver Medallion both look like decent colts.
12 Clip. Great analysis. Agree 100%. Think Silver Medallion can be a real factor if he transfers to dirt. I will get down on him in the future wager, and I think the price will be right.
As I've commented somewhere before, I think the El Camino Real Derby was the strongest race run of the three preps run last weekend. The winner Silver Medallion made a nice transition from turf to tapeta. Now he will have to show us he can run on dirt. A logical spot may be the G2 Rebel at Oaklwan, or the G2 San Felipe at Santa Anita. He looks like a nice horse, wonder if Asmussen will keep Baze aboard? As for the place horse Jakesam, I was impressed. He stretched his speed all the way and a solid race. Still not sure what to think of him quite yet. Now for Positive Response, this was a learning race. I think of all the top 4 finishers he'll be the one who gets the most out of this race. I like his style and now we just need to know if he can run on dirt. Comma to the Top, needed that race. What he also needs is to get Corey Nakatani off his back. They are not a good fit. Someone like Joe Talamo, or Mike Smith would be a good jockey for CTTT. I'm not willing to disregard him quite yet. But I will need to see him run much better in the San Felipe.
Any idea on where Silver Medallion might be headed next?

Related Pages

Meet Don August

I have been involved in horse racing, from a fan to sportswriter, for the past 30 years. The first time my dad took me to the track, I picked a horse named "Black Tornado" and when he won, I was hooked.  From then on, I spent weekends and occasional school days at the race track, and my enjoyment of the sport led me to try my hand at being a jockey agent, which i did for 3 years. When that didn't work out as I had hoped, I concentrated on my writing career by covering big races and doing summer fair handicapping, off and on, for the Contra Costa Times.

Today, I stay involved in the sport by being part of a group that currently owns two horses stabled at Golden Gate Fields. As all owners, we have dreams of someday having that special horse.  Besides writing about horse racing I enjoy covering many sports and have had the honor of meeting and writing about some incredible athletes.

Related Stories

Best of the Blogs

Top Stories