tpatelzick

he is a her

What do you mean, he ran a great race. He stalked off the pace by 2 lengths behind the early speed horses, then crushed everyone in the turn and home stretch. Tizway didnt set the slow pace. In a wide open BC Classic, he has to be one to consider.

that is true the rankings are silly, but fun just the same.

Is he better than Frankel? Shackleford? Coil? Lets not forget those horse that are taking some time off to rest or train, Nehro, Animal Kingdom, Mucho MachoMan. There might even be some fillies that could out run him, Its Tricky, Turbulent Descent. Remember just because he wins a G2, that doesnt make him the best. He is a good 10F horse write now and thats all we know for sure. Still needs a couple G1 wins.

is

The older female list is nails! However, can any horse be ranked higher than Goldikova?

I cant see uncle mo being 5-1 maybe 6-1 if, he does next weeks work on three legs. DI should be the same. Both horse need the "good trip" to win

Certainly like him in my top 5, as for winning, pedigree concerns me about his distance. One more thing… which race did he win??? I will agree that he does look good. Arch3 seems to have good form and the pedigree. Just don’t know if he is fast enough. (Also like DI, MMM, soldat, and UM)

Brent-Did you get all your information from "fullcardreports"? This just in... 15 0f the last 16 winers have been fast (exception on every list is MTB), Brethren needs to run a speed figure over 95! Althpugh he does have good pedigree;-)

Happens every year. Last year you need to add Eskendrya and Winslow Homer, both at the top of the board before getting off the trail. I seem to remember Drosselmeyer was hurt for the derby as well last year.