NativeDancer

Ruthenia finished last of ten. Now maybe Nayla and all her aliases will stop rating this horse 10 so her rating can go to somewhere it belongs.

He probably will go off odds on, it is just a $21k allowance race.

Mike, you don’t tell the truth. Yesterday, after you jumped in, I checked your ratings and you had Private Rules rated “10”. I see you have now covered up that fact. If I were Eric Fein, I would be embarrassed to be related to you guys. This whole thread started because I am fairly new to this site and asked the simple question why this horse was rated so high. With very little research and you guys jumping out of the woodwork, it was easy to determine that you guys over-rate Eric Fein’s horses for some perverted reason to make them seem better than they really are. I not sure why you guys also over-rate this horse, but if you feel connected some how, it gets a “10”. Looking at today’s ratings, very few horses have been rated, but sure enough, all of the over-rated horses nayla is pushing have even higher ratings today. You guys are sick and should consider seeking mental health. Plez2k10 has now given some more recent reasonable ratings, but that was after I revealed her “10” rating for this horse and at the same time she gave G1 winner Tell A Kelly a “1”. Mike and nayla are hopeless causes. I am done with this conversation. I’ll leave you guessing what current year G1 winner I co-own, but it’s not one that has been mentioned in this thread and I certainly wouldn’t trade them for Musket Man. After the nominations come out, if you are invited, maybe we can meet at this year’s Eclipse Awards.

Mike, I know you want to divert the attention away from both nayla’s and your outlandish “10” ratings. I see you also rated Private Rules a “10”. Wow a one-time maiden winner with $32 in earnings that has finished last in two of his last three starts you guys considered a “horse of the year” type! I know nayla is biased and is somehow connected to Eric Fein based on her comments about meeting him in the winners circle and her comment yesterday that “They should rename The Tampa Bay Derby the Eric Fein Derby”. You must be related somehow too. I guess you guys get you jollies over-rating horses so you can pretend they are better than they really are. The connections should consider running their horses where they have a chance of winning. I am not going to argue where Muskat Man should be rated, other than what I already said about many better horses being rated lower than he is because you, nayla and possibly others skewing the ratings. No hater here, lover of the sport and doing my small part to point out your abuses. Apparently you have been called out in other threads too.

Nayla1268, you should defend your “10” ratings, because they make no sense to me. Let’s take a look: 1) Private Rules – only a maiden win. 2) Schoolyard Dreams – only maiden and allowance N1X. 3) CC’s Pal – maiden, allowance N1X and N2X. 4) Musket Man – one win in eight starts this year (one minor stakes $75k), finished 8th or 9 in last race (Cigar Mile). The common denominator in all four of your picks is they are owned by Eric Fein and trained by Derek Ryan. Clearly, for some reason, you are trying to make these horses rated higher than they should be. For instance Musket Man is the 17th highest rated horse on this site. Rated unbelievably higher than many current year G1 winners that are better horses and in better form than Musket Man. I suggest you read the site’s guidelines for voting where a “10” rating is for “horse of the year” types.

I was just asking why this horse was rated so high. At the time it was rated higher than More Than Real. The ratings are no good if a few folks try to through off the ratings. When I first checked, either nayla1268 or plez2k10 had rated Tell A Kelly with a 1 rating and juiced Ruthenia. Not out of shape, I was just asking the question. Yes, I agree that she may deserve a higher rating in the future.

Well clearly nayla1268 has an agenda giving this horse and two allowance horses a 10 rating. My point was simple. She won a maiden and then beat a weak stakes field. The second place horse she beat couldn't win a N1X next time out!

Why is this horse rated so high? It has only beat maidens and only beat another by a small margin and that horse lost next out in a 1N1X!