• It's all Favorite Tale in the Fabulous Strike.Posted 3 hours ago
  • Lavender Chrissie romps past Calamity Kate in the Zia Park Oaks.Posted 5 hours ago
  • Mobile Bay wins the Zia Park Derby, while International Star fades to fourth.Posted 5 hours ago
  • It's all Lewys Vaporizer in the $200,000 Steel Valley Sprint at Mahoning Valley.Posted 2 days ago
  • Solid Wager rolls late in the Cary Grant; Big Macher last at 2-5.Posted 3 days ago
  • Dolphus (Lookin at Lucky), 1/2 brother to Rachel Alexandra, wins his career debut at Fair Grounds.Posted 3 days ago
  • Rusty Slipper proves best in the 11-furlong Red Carpet.Posted 4 days ago
  • Exaggerator holds off Sunny Ridge to win the $1 million Delta Downs Jackpot.Posted 4 days ago
  • Button Down soars to victory in the Cardinal.Posted 4 days ago
  • Jet Black Magic pulls the upset in the Delta Downs Princess.Posted 4 days ago

Why Can't It Be This Simple?


The news came in today that Preakness champion, Shackleford is confirmed as a go for next week's Belmont Stakes. It was not a surprise, as trainer Dale Romans has been saying all along, that provided the son of Forestry was thriving, he would enter him in the third leg of racing's Triple Crown. I took the news as extremely positive nonetheless.


The simple fact that both the Kentucky Derby winner, Animal Kingdom, and Shackleford are going to run in the Belmont is noteworthy. They are bucking the trend of not only the Belmont, but also a disturbing one that plagues all of thoroughbred racing. Our best horses no longer race as often as they should, and they certainly do not face each other often enough. We are in the age devoid of rivalries. Alydar and Affirmed tested each other ten times, and all by the time that the two hit the wire in the 1978 Travers. Rivalries like that are likely gone forever, but this year's Belmont provides a promising trend reversal.


Believe it or not, only 2 times in the last 15 years, have a Derby winner and a Preakness winner met in the Belmont. Only Afleet Alex and Giacomo in 2005, and Point Given and Monarchos in 2001, decided the rubber match at Belmont. Sad, but true. Granted several of those years were not eligible, as the same horse won the first two legs, but still there have been many opportunities that went unfulfilled.
Because of this trend, I expressed my skepticism of seeing the match-up following the Preakness. Happily, I was wrong. Kudos to Team Valor and Graham Motion for deciding to run their distance bred colt in the Belmont despite having their Triple Crown dreams narrowly dashed in Baltimore. Kudos to Michael Lauffer, W.D. Cubbedge, and Dale Romans for deciding to run their flourishing colt in the Belmont despite the grueling test that the race promises for a horse that likes to run fast early.
We've known Animal Kingdom was going to run for a few days now, but the Shackleford announcement just came in, and good news it is. Perhaps more owners will follow suit, do the sporting thing, and run their best horses in more big races.
Shackleford will not be my top pick in the Belmont, but I commend their decision to run. He's a good horse, and he makes the Belmont a better race. His addition allows for a rubber match of our two classic winners in front of a national audience on NBC. It is a match-up that reverses a disturbing trend in racing. There can be no doubt that this is good for racing.
Maybe someday it can be as simple as this again … The Derby winner is a good horse. The Preakness winner is a good horse. Shouldn't good horses run against each other in big races like the Belmont Stakes?
[Who do you think will win the rubber match in the 2011 Belmont Stakes?]


comments powered by Disqus

Older Comments about Why Can't It Be This Simple?...

This is so exciting! It woud be great to have a nice rivalry like in 78.
Yes, Mucho Macho Man makes 3 ... hopefully this is the start of a new trend!
Another good thing is that besides Shackle and AK, 5 other Derby horses are returning for the Belmont. Also 3 horse coming into the Belmont will have run in all 3 races. When was the last time we saw something like this?

Related Pages

Related Stories

Top Stories