Ticker
  • Minding rolls home an easy winner of the Group 1 Pretty Polly Stakes at The Curragh.Posted 22 hours ago
  • Melatonin powers home a strong winner of the Gold Cup at Santa Anita.Posted 1 day ago
  • Lord Nelson lunges late to nip Subtle Indian in the Triple Bend.Posted 1 day ago
  • By the Moon proves best in the Grade 3 Bed O' Roses at Belmont Park.Posted 1 day ago
  • Mo Tom finds a trouble free trip, and rolls home an easy Ohio Derby winner.Posted 1 day ago
  • Isabella Sings strolls to victory in Monmouth's Eatontown.Posted 1 day ago
  • Sarah Sis makes all the running as the Chicago Handicap favorite.Posted 1 day ago
  • Harzand holds off Idaho in the Irish Derby to become a dual Derby winnerPosted 1 day ago
  • Far From Over wins his return today at Belmont after more than 16 months away.Posted 2 days ago
  • Champion Untapable has been retired from racing, according to owner, Ron Winchell.Posted 7 days ago

I'll Have Another the next Sunday Silence?

A Kentucky Derby and Preakness (gr. I) winner is largely shunned by American breeders and thus sold to Japanese interests that stepped up and made a fair offer to the horse's owner. If the story of I'll Have Another's sale last week struck a familiar chord, it is because 22 years ago an eerily similar scenario played out over dual classic winner and 1989 Horse of the Year Sunday Silence.
 
The son of Halo would go on to have a legendary stallion career in Japan, becoming that country's leading sire 13 consecutive years and now its leading broodmare sire. Yet, domestic farms in the past month showed the same lack of enthusiasm for this year's dual classic winner, I'll Have Another, pointing to the fact the son of Flower Alley was an $11,000 yearling and a $35,000 2-year-old, indicating the young horse had conformation issues. Also, you have to go back four generations in his female family to find the type of runners and producers that quicken the heart. Here again, the similarities between I'll Have Another and Sunday Silence are striking.

 

  Read More

 

comments powered by Disqus

Older Comments about I'll Have Another the next Sunday Silence?...

That would be very ironic, Yukichan. I would still love to see it though :)
I find the last sentence in this article hugely prophetic. One could argue that perhaps Sunday Silence would not have been the successful sire he was in Japan had he stayed in America because American breeders would not have sent their best mares to him. Shadai Farms made an enormous investment in quality European and American broodmares (as they and other farms continue to do). IHA will get quality broodmares in Japan no doubt. Probably some who raced in America. Wouldn't it be ironic if in 4 yrs time, we have a IHA cross with say Wickedly Perfect or Ginger Punch, both in Japan, who returns to the US representing Japan and wins a Breeder's Cup?
I'm not sure of the exact figures, but I believe Hancock got far more than his 250k per share paid by the Japanese. The same was probably true for IHA. My question is a bit more philosophical: Would Sunday Silence have been as successful of a stallion in the US, due to less genetic diversity by other Halo descendents? It will be interesting to see IHA's progeny as many of of the mares he will be bred are heirs of Sunday Silence. Still a lot of diversity there, though.
Another good question Miss Lovely TampaBay, keep them coming, works the ageless brain.
American breeders did not shun him, they just were not prepared to pay millions for him.
This horse has proven himself. It is beyond odd that American breeders pass over him. He deserves to be here in the states producing more good horses. I love this horse.

Related Pages

Related Stories

Top Stories