• Lady Shipman dominates in Saratoga's Coronation Cup.Posted 1 day ago
  • Stopchargingmaria out-duels Untapable to win the G3 Shuvee.Posted 2 days ago
  • American Pharoah wins the Haskell completely in hand!Posted 2 days ago
  • Heart to Heart takes them wire to wire in the G3 Oceanport.Posted 2 days ago
  • Casual Smile closes from second last to win the G3 Matchmaker Stakes.Posted 2 days ago
  • Bradester snags the G2 Monmouth Cup in front-running fashion.Posted 2 days ago
  • Rachel's Valentina, daughter of champion Rachel Alexandra, wins her debut at the Spa!Posted 2 days ago
  • Beholder wins the G1 Clement L. Hirsch for fun!Posted 3 days ago
  • Texas Red returns to the winner's circle with a Jim Dandy victory over Frosted!Posted 3 days ago
  • Red Rifle squeezes through rivals to win the Bowling Green.Posted 3 days ago

I'll Have Another and Bodemeister, the new Affirmed and Alydar?

I'll Have Another defeats Bodemeister in the Preakness
An exciting Triple Crown rivalry was born Saturday in the Preakness Stakes. I’ll Have Another, ridden masterfully by California handicappers’ secret weapon Mario Gutierrez, let Bodemeister and Mike Smith have it their own way winging it on the lead throughout much of the race.  
I’ll Have Another was four wide following Bodemeister around the first turn. Throughout the early stages, Gutierrez kept I’ll Have Another in the clear on the outside in fourth place, about a two lengths behind the reasonable fractions set by Bodemeister. Around the far turn, Gutierrez made a winning move by angling to the rail to save ground.  At the top of the stretch, Bodemeister set down for the drive and spurted away with his usual quick acceleration. For a few yards, it looked like a replay of the Kentucky Derby as Bodemeister sprinted away to a three length lead and appeared well on his way to winning the race.  However, I’ll Have Another, having saved precious ground, was hot on his heels, closing with every step.  In the final furlong, the two foes battled it out to the wire. In a thrilling conclusion, I’ll Have Another won the Preakness Stakes by a long neck over the once again courageous Bodemeister.



The 2012 Kentucky Derby and Preakness Stakes bring to mind the heroic actions by the last Triple Crown hero Affirmed.  Although their running styles were different, both Affirmed and I’ll Have Another won their respective Triple Crown legs by the exact same distance over the same rivals. Affirmed held on in the Kentucky Derby to win by 1 ½ lengths over his gallant foe Alydar, and took the Preakness Stakes by a neck, besting the same opponent. I’ll Have Another cut into Bodemeister’s lead in the Kentucky Derby, winning by 1 ½ lengths and the Preakness Stakes was decided by a neck victory.



With the Triple Crown on the line for the first time since 2008, the question on everyone’s lips is “Can he do it again?”  Does I’ll Have Another have the pedigree and running style to win the Belmont Stakes, or will he emulate another Kentucky Derby/Preakness victor, Real Quiet, and lose the Belmont by the slimmest of margins, to Bodemeister or a newcomer?



Both I’ll Have Another and Bodemeister have stamina oriented pedigrees. I’ll Have Another’s young sire Flower Alley never attempted 1 ½ miles. However, his sire Distorted Humor has given us 2010 Belmont Stakes hero Drosselmeyer and four other stakes winners at 1 ½ miles.  So far, Flower Alley appears to be passing along stamina genes to his offspring. 



I’ll Have Another’s damsire Arch is a young stallion.  He’s produced two stakes winners at 1 ½ miles. I’ll Have Another’s second damsire Pleasant Tap is the broodmare sire of stakes winners at 1 ½ miles as well, so there are no issues pedigree wise for getting the distance. 



Bodemeister’s sire Empire Maker ruined Funny Cide’s bid for Triple Crown glory in 2003. Currently, the young stallion has sired only one winner at 1 ½ miles, but since it’s a seldom carded distance, this isn’t surprising. As a broodmare sire, Storm Cat is represented by four stakes winners at the Belmont Stakes distance. 



I’ll Have Another’s running style benefited him in both the Kentucky Derby and Preakness. The colt normally prefers to sit within a couple of lengths of the front runners, but he showed a new dimension in the Derby, sitting as far back as eight lengths off of the lead before making his move around the far turn. I’ll Have Another shows maturity and appears to be quite tractable, meaning that his jockey could probably place him anywhere in the race and still win. This versatile running style will be the key to winning the Belmont Stakes.



Research shows that mid-pack runners and pace pressers have combined to win eleven of the last twenty-two editions of the Belmont Stakes. One run stalkers have been successful eight times, while only two front runners were victorious.  



At this point, the Belmont Stakes is shaping up with few horses that have the pedigree to handle 1 ½ miles.  It’s true that last year’s Belmont hero Ruler On Ice had a poor stamina oriented pedigree, however, he benefited from a sloppy track that wasn’t kind to closers. His win was an anomaly.  If Bob Baffert doesn’t send Bodemeister for a rematch, the silver-haired trainer could send the rapidly developing Paynter, who like Bodemeister, is owned by Zayat Stables. 



Paynter (Awesome Again – Tizso, by Cee’s Tizzy) could well be I’ll Have Another’s most dangerous foe in the Belmont Stakes. He’s lightly raced and has the pedigree to handle 1 ½ miles.  The late-maturing colt’s sire Awesome Again was a ten furlong specialist, winning Canada’s prestigious Queen’s Plate, Hawthorne Gold Cup, Saratoga’s Breeders’ Cup Handicap and the Breeders’ Cup Classic. He’s sired one stakes winner at 1 ½ miles. Paynter’s damsire Cee’s Tizzy is best known as the sire of two-time Classic hero Tiznow. His daughters haven’t produced a stakes winner past 1 1/8 miles, but Paynter is closely related to Tiznow, as his dam Tizso is a full sister to the stallion.  Additionally, Paynter’s distaff line is boosted by the presence of his second damsire, Seattle Song, winner of the now defunct Washington D.C. Invitational at 1 ½ miles.  



Paynter and I’ll Have Another have similar running styles. Both usually sit directly behind the pace, however, both colt have won on the lead as well.  On Preakness day, Paynter outclassed a group of allowance runners by 5 ¾ lengths.



I’ll Have Another is racing’s best hope of a Triple Crown hero since Big Brown and Smarty Jones.  He hasn’t shown the brilliance of Smarty Jones or Big Brown, but instead, compares favorably to Real Quiet and our last Triple Crown victor, Affirmed. I’ll Have Another has the pedigree, running style and toughness to win the Triple Crown. All he needs is another brilliant ride by Mario Gutierrez.


--Laurie Ross, HRN Pedigree Expert


comments powered by Disqus

Older Comments about I'll Have Another and Bodemeister, the new Affirmed and Alydar?...

No Way..Bodemeister is no Alydar.
IHO is special and as good as Bode is, this is not a good spot for him.
No, Bodemieister is out.. not going to Belmont. Alydar never gave up
Excellent analysis, Laurie!

Related Pages

Related Stories

Top Stories